I Never Promised You a Rose Garden (1977)

16 May 2023

Rating: 2.5/5

After a suicide attempt, Kathleen Quinlan, playing 16-year-old Deborah, is admitted to an institution. Straight away, we experience the whispers that are in her head — “traitor”, “secrets” — and a person in stereotypical tribal clothing and face paint that does not appear to be real

More and more, fantasy intersects with reality, in which tribe-like gods rule and who forces her to hurt herself as penance

Her time in the institution is populated with the theater kid version of insanity, where everyone performs song and dance, disassociating or instigating fights. I can’t speak to the realism; it’s just cliche, especially post-One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest

The real heart of the movie is in the individual therapy sessions with Bibi Andersson, where Deborah expresses her private language and learns, little by little, how to trust someone other than herself and how to experience genuine human pain

The passage of time in the movie is horrifying, where a couple of days feel like they have passed, and those lead to years lost. Still, as a viewer, it’s hard not to feel like the ending is sudden and maybe even unearned

Overall, not a stellar movie, but it found moments of warmth that helped it through

Stray Thoughts


See Review on Letterboxd